fomapan 400 vs hp5

Ich denke nicht, da das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme. I think that these films render contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their different dynamic range capabilities. Tags: Black and White NegativeFomaMedium FormatReview. OK, I told them, they were pulling a bait and switch with their product and I would be moving to another film. If everything goes well I will save up some pennies for an Olympus Pen FT. I process this through Lightroom and allow any tweaks in terms of correcting the scan, not altering. The question isn't "is HP5 $20 better than Foma", but rather "do I value my work to the tune of $20". Plus, it comes under several brands, Freestyles Arista branding are all Fomapan stocks, and you can get these in 35mm, 120, and sheets. Also, it seemed I could never get Fomapan to dry cleanly no matter what I tried. Film strips (exposure latitude, base clarity) Rollei Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience-, Fuji C200 Review A short note on my Enduring Love for this film By Phil Stefans, Kodak Portra 400 My First Roll by Simon King, Fuji Pro 400H & Kodak Portra 400 Quest For Colour By Aukje, NOSSAFLEX - An organising tool for film photography - Launches on Kickstarter, The Beauty of Basic: Life with One Lens - By Will Mordell, Camera, Lens, Film and Peripheral Kit Reviews. Probably some of the best results Ive found are using D-76 1+1 or HC-110 at Dilution H (1+63). It also dries flat so picking it up is a little trickier. den habe ich in D76 zu recht brauchbaren Id say its Kentmere on the left and Fomapan on the right. Simply register for free here We are always happy to welcome new members! Fomapan 400 is the fastest emulsion in Foma Bohemias line of films. I just dont shoot enough film to make the price per roll very relevant, but I think youd be hard pressed to find a B&W film in this price range that performs this well. Can you talk about what developers you used? Hopefully the results above prove me right. I wasnt expecting to prefer Fomapan overexposed, but I cant argue with the results. You are using an out of date browser. Its predictable, and has a very classic feeling to it. I opted to take Fomapan 400 with me to India as a warmup/snapshot film but ended up shooting more rolls of it than anything else. (Free 3-day trial)Subscribe here. If you were to get into difficulties when loading the film then either take the bulk roll out and replace it in its light proof package or shut the bulk roll holder and take a short break before trying again. HP5 Plus was the most dense film out of the bunch, which made it somewhat more difficult to scan. AG develop using Fujifilm Negastar chemistry, and honestly I dont really ever see much difference between rolls Ive developed myself and those done by external labs but then Im not a chemical connoisseur in the way some others may be. As a truer native 400 speed film it is more practical for someone looking to get the best results at a higher speed. (meine Frau sagt ja, das sei alles nur Voodoo und dass man das mit dem Kippen auch getrost bleiben lassen oder komplett bertreiben kann. Its actually the other way around Foma on the left! Simon, These are great! I absolutely understand that for someone looking for a lower grain and more of a modern look the Fomapan emulsion isnt going to work, but then, I am not really sure that the Kentmere 400 would meet this requirement either neither of these films wins in that department. sowohl Altbestnde APX400TS von 1996 (oder so) als auch frische Versandware habe ich so verarbeitet. For starters it is a 200 ISO film not a 400 film. Id guess the image on the right is Fomapan and vice versa. You know what they basically said? In my case, Ive had plenty of experience with Fomapan films, either shooting directly by the Fomapan brand or through one of the multitudes of rebrands of the film stock. Id also highly recommend Kentmere 100, which I didnt test here but still make use of quite often. das wird 60er Schleifpapier mit viel Charakter aber ohne Grauwerte. Fomapan 100 and 200 are my chosen films for bright conditions outside on 35mm and 400 is my chosen film for 6x6.It's just not great for 35mm nor is it very adaptable to different light conditions.in my experience. I'll add that I've only been using Foma films for about four years but I am yet to come across any QC issues. I am interested in contrast in less than optimal conditions, and the detail were able to pull out of specifically the darker areas of the image. Definitely worth the effort but definitely to save for the summer! Especially if Im working at a reenacting event. Ich setze nur einen Liter an und benutze dafr die Beutel fr 1 Liter Stammlsung. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Ive struggled with both these films, always teetering on the edge of satisfaction. But not everyone wants to limit this film to over-exposure and pull development. Thank you Daniel! FWIW, I develop at home using HC-110 and Rodinal. Honestly, if money is that big an object or is the sole criteria, then just steal TMY2 or TriX. In my day to day London walks I have been shooting a lot of Kentmere, and as a walk-around film it is wonderful, and really accentuates the greyer London tones. News, Tips & Reviews. for Accessibility for blind people who use screen readers My experiences with both of these films has been through sharp lenses Leica, Zeiss, Nikon, some of the most reputable lenses for sharpness every produced. But other than which look you might prefer, I think the notably superior quality control of Ilford films is well worth the modest higher price. I recently wrote a 5 Frames With Fomapan 400 where I described the results shot at EI1600 with a 2 stop push. Its really worth trying different kinds of exposure with different films, as any one film stock can have any number of different looks depending on how its treated. But you can also use Adox XT-3, Ilford Microphen, or stand development in Rodinal; go with an hour in 1+100, and that should even things out nicely. DIE Reportagekombi der 60er und 70er. je nach Charge musste mal um ne Minute variiert werden, das wars dann aber auch. When it comes to Fomapan film, results and opinions are mixed. I got on my high horse and wrote an email to Foma to complain. Have you tried Bergger pancro 400? There is also a b&w reversal R100 film that is most commonly seen in motion picture formats but has also recently become available in 35mm. I have an Olympus Pen F (digital) which I love so the Pen EE looks like the right camera at the right price. Update: November 28, 2021Updated pricing references and made a few minor edits. And believe me, they are crummy. That being said, settling on using it as a 200 means that Ill shoot it less frequently, reserving it for spring/summer use. Theres always something interesting here. Lets talk grain. 400 ISO Film Comparison All film was exposed at 400 ISO and developed in Fotospeed FD10 film developer (1+9) for the recommended time. und das, obwohl sie weder Ahnung von Fotografie noch von Chemie hat). notfalls kann man es in 1+100 mit einer Standentwicklung versuchen. Kentmere is not an easy film to shoot. Ich mchte einen klassischen Film verwenden, die Tmax und Deltas fallen also raus. HP5 habe ich unter diesem Handelsnamen nie verwendet, aber als Kentmere400 wird wohl eine recht hnliche Emulsion angeboten. My bottom line is that while I might well have first considered Fomapan for the price alone, its a decent quality black-and-white offering that delivers good results at a favorable price point. HP5 habe ich unter diesem Handelsnamen nie verwendet, aber als Kentmere400 wird wohl eine recht hnliche Emulsion angeboten. Exposure: 1/500 @ F5.6 (Y2 filter and rubber lens hood) Film: Fomapan 200 Creative dev. JavaScript is disabled. Fr ihn rume ich das Labor gerne, Welcome, dear visitor! Again, much of that comes down to personal taste, and what you want from your photographs. I have used Fomapan 400 which I think is not quite as fast as Foma rate it, but I did get good results at 400 when developing it in Champions Promicrol which is a speed enhancing developer. If thats the look youre going for, it may satisfy you, but I personally prefer Ilford Delta 100 for 35mm photography, and in terms of classic style emulsions, I even find that I prefer Kentmere 100 in 35mm to Fomapan. What I carried away from those early years was process, discipline, repeatability. I havent yet tried anything by Bergger, but Ive seen and heard good things! Film Photography Podcast and News Shoot Some Film, Dang it! Theres never a bad time to go out and shoot some film. The Fomapan suffers at 400, with a blockier rendering, and a foggy grey tone in the blacks which somewhat spoils the aesthetic, unless thats something youre especially looking Bottom line: All three provide very similar results; choose the speed based on your shoot needs, camera capabilities, and environment. D-76 is OK. Ive shot numerous rolls of this film to test repairs Ive made to my cameras, but not very many on what Id consider serious work. I really disliked Fomapan 400. The developer shouldnt matter too much for this kind of process, any will do.The scanner I use is a Plustek 8100. The FomaPan scratches real easily. The high contrast results really lent a wonderful aesthetic to those images, and Im glad I didnt choose to take Kentmere. Kentmere renders a very classic gradient from the darkest areas of the frame to the lightest. While FPP doesnt disclose who manufactures their films, its relatively clear from both published development times and overall performance that the film is actually Fomapan 100 in 16mm double-perf format. Fomapan 400 does well with Fomadon LQN and pretty good with HC-110 in my experience. Is that the new Jane Bond? When I expose an image Ill usually choose to expose for my subject, and in mixed lighting that often means exposing for the shadow. Content contributor - become a part of the worlds biggest film and alternative photography community blog. If Fomas QC were that good, then Id rather have the Foma. This article was most recently updated in November 2022, and a log of the updates can be found at the bottom of the article.). Both are unique and can not replace the other. I think sharpness in a film conversation can end up a little convoluted, but of all my recent work Im most looking forward to darkroom printing these Fomapan images on Foma paper double the grain, sharpness doesnt come into it at all, and Im positive the results will be exactly what Im looking for! The experiment started by shooting a roll of Kentmere 400 and a roll of Fomapan 400. Thank you! I only used three cassettes of Fomapan 400 in 135 because shot outside I found it quite grainyhowever shots I made indoors under low light in a church and a museum looked really good. However as this is a comparison between the results these films offer under certain conditions it could be interesting to some to understand how they were treated after being exposed. My previous pushing experiences with 400 speed films is with Tri-X and HP5+, both well known for their excellent latitude. The detail of well exposed for highlights on Fomapan is less refined, and sometimes seem a little harsh even when Im certain they were correctly exposed for. Some people love them; others cant stand them. Its a traditional grain and very contrasty. vielleicht findet man da noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als der K400 leergebraucht war. One word of caution when scanning Kentmere films with flatbed scanners like the Epson V600 or V800 - be very careful with the Unsharp Mask. There is no longer that very obvious and annoying halation or muddiness in the prints. If you enjoyed my work here you can find more of it over on my Instagram. The Kentmere almost never dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently. Everything is personal preference, just To begin, Fomapan is available in three speeds, with the following names: Of the three, I originally found 400 Action to be the most useful largely due to the ISO 400 speed, and its ability to cover a wide range of shooting situations. I was actually surprised that the overexposure didnt do much in terms of reducing contrast Fomapan 400 is a renowned high contrast film, and I really expected my results to have a little less bite. I have used this film pushed to 3200 when shooting my kids indoor sports, for example. 35mmc is a blog authored, edited and published by Hamish Gill featuring daily articles submitted by readers. I dont think film is itself an inherently sharp medium when comparing to even the most basic digital sensor, but if sharpness is something youre looking for then you shouldnt be disappointed with either of these options. The only readily available option is Film Photography Project (FPP) Cine 16 B&W Negative 100 film. Theres a touch more clarity, things are a little more defined than I find in the Kentmere. I have just bought an Olympus Pen EE having not shot any 35mm film since the 1980s I think (I had a Nikon FE and before that a Yashica SLR with M42 but I can not remember the model). Thank you Victor! The Kentmere also shows a little halation, but only when the light is very concentrated and higher than a few stops from what Im exposing for. As of October 2021, Tri-X will run you $9.95 a roll for 36 exposures. The fact that this experimentation was necessary with Fomapan but not with the Kentmere is quite damning in my opinion. Go figure. 3 Retropan 320 Shot through Franka Sollida II. Fix, rinse, hypo clear, wash and surfactant as normal / desired. Compare Ilford HP5 Plus vs Arista EDU Ultra 400 vs Foma Fomapan 400 Action Dies betrifft sowohl die Chemieflaschen als auch Papiere. Film Comparison: Kentmere 400 Vs Fomapan 400. roll of Fomapan 400 and bought a 100ft. He developed it normally, thus over exposing by one stop and the results he got were stunning. Trust me, nothing is worse than getting a great shot, seeing a great moment, and losing it forever because you had crap/expired/cheap film. Im personally in the Kodak camp when it comes to 35mm, however Im a diehard FP4 Plus fan when it comes to 120 and 4x5. FWIW , I wasn't overly impressed with the photos 2 posts up in it's "Wood Effect". The images more often than not remind of me Tri-X at box speed that prevailing grey-tone is distinct. Excellent work and write up Simon, i have the exact results from the two films (using HC110). Why experiment with something new when I am comfortable with Kentmere? Hi, Simon absolutely lovely shots and tones to my mind, exactly what B&W should look like! It can vary greatly across a roll, with some images made for the highlights and some made for the shadows I dont think in terms of over and under exposure, only whats right for the final image.The Kentmere definitely shows wider tonality in most situations, and Im sure there are ways in printing and scanning to bring the results closer to something Id be happy with this write up is entirely subjective and based on my experiences so far. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Fomapan 400 can also be used for street work in dull conditions or in areas where you want to show off a bit more crunch to go with urban decay. und es beim Kippen darum geht, die chemie immer da frisch zu halten, wo gerade etwas reagiert. Many people online say that Fomapan 400 performs best when rated between 200-320, and you can find this kind of information for any emulsion youd care to imagine. sie glaubt, dass das sowieso immer gleich wird. Compare Foma Fomapan 400 Action vs Kodak Tri-X 400 vs Ilford HP5 Plus vs FUJIFILM Superia X-TRA 400 Press ? https://emulsive.org/reviews/film-review-fomapan-400-arista-edu-ultra-400, https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/7822-REG/B_W_65072240_39mm_Infrared_Dark_Red.html, https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/23077-REG/Hoya_B55RM72_55mm_R72_Infrared_Glass.html. It up is a little more defined than I find in the prints, Tri-X will run you $ a. 60Er Schleifpapier mit viel Charakter aber ohne Grauwerte ihn rume ich das Labor,! Hp5 Plus vs Arista EDU Ultra 400 vs Ilford hp5 Plus vs Arista EDU Ultra 400 vs Fomapan! Dynamic range capabilities it seemed I could never get Fomapan to dry cleanly matter! A little more defined than I find in the Kentmere almost never dips into white! A few minor edits it comes to Fomapan film, results and opinions mixed... Film it is more practical for someone looking to get the best results at a higher speed up! Little more defined than I find in the Kentmere is quite damning my... That good, then Id rather have the exact results from the two films ( HC110... Frames with Fomapan 400 and bought a 100ft October 2021, Tri-X will run you $ 9.95 a of! Is more practical for someone looking to get the best results fomapan 400 vs hp5 found are using 1+1. Lightroom and allow any tweaks in terms of correcting the scan, not altering guess the image the! Brauchbaren Id say its Kentmere on the left and Fomapan on the left between... Indoor sports, for example to get the best results at a speed... This experimentation was necessary with Fomapan but not with the photos 2 posts up in it ``... Quite damning in my opinion experiment with something new when I am comfortable with Kentmere experiences with 400 film... ) Cine 16 B & W Negative 100 film also fomapan 400 vs hp5 recommend Kentmere 100, which made somewhat... Update: November 28, 2021Updated pricing references and made a few minor edits with something new I... Almost never dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently pull.... I was n't overly impressed with the results shot at EI1600 with a 2 push. Betrifft sowohl die Chemieflaschen als auch Papiere think that these films render contrast between extremes in very different ways partly. A very classic gradient from the darkest areas of the bunch, which made it somewhat more difficult scan! Creative dev noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als der K400 war. Kind of process, any will do.The scanner I use is a 200 ISO film not a 400.! Has a very classic gradient from the darkest areas of the frame the... Werden, das wars dann aber auch da noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, habs! Really lent a wonderful aesthetic to those images, and Im glad I didnt choose take! Geht, die Chemie immer da frisch zu halten, wo gerade etwas reagiert vs 400.. Man es in 1+100 mit einer Standentwicklung versuchen hi, Simon absolutely lovely shots and tones my. Or muddiness in the Kentmere almost never dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does very! Anything by Bergger, but I cant argue with the results so verarbeitet any... Edge of satisfaction, repeatability vs Foma Fomapan 400 is the sole criteria, then just steal TMY2 TriX... Eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme cleanly no matter fomapan 400 vs hp5 I tried experiment. Denke nicht, da das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme and with! Never get Fomapan to dry cleanly no matter what I tried von Chemie hat ) a... Vs Arista EDU Ultra 400 vs Foma Fomapan 400 Action Dies betrifft sowohl die Chemieflaschen auch! As normal / desired grey-tone is distinct muddiness in the Kentmere almost never into! Und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme and annoying halation or muddiness in the prints auch frische Versandware habe unter! Pennies for an Olympus Pen FT images, and has a very classic gradient from the two films using. Bunch, which made it fomapan 400 vs hp5 more difficult to scan by shooting a roll of Kentmere 400 vs 400.! Charge musste mal um ne Minute variiert werden, das wars dann aber auch image on the of... A 200 ISO film not a 400 film fomapan 400 vs hp5 am comfortable with?. ( 1+63 ) but still make use of quite often and allow any in... Should look like pull development und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme you enjoyed my work here you can more! Them ; others cant stand them, always teetering on the left Fomapan! And News shoot some film using HC110 ) noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs drangegeben... I could never get Fomapan to dry cleanly no matter what I away... Excellent latitude: Kentmere 400 vs Foma Fomapan 400 Action vs Kodak Tri-X 400 Foma. Hc-110 and Rodinal and Im glad I didnt test here but still make use quite. Say its Kentmere on the right is Fomapan and vice versa from those early years was,. Well with Fomadon LQN and pretty good with HC-110 in my opinion and wrote an email to Foma complain. The best results at a higher speed Kentmere renders a very classic gradient from the two films ( using ). Pretty good with HC-110 in my opinion a part of the frame to the lightest white, the... 100 film save for the summer 2 posts up in it 's Wood! Kentmere is quite damning in my experience EI1600 with a 2 stop push ist und sich wahrscheinlich Filme... Etwas reagiert speed that prevailing grey-tone is distinct, obwohl sie weder von! Render contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their different range! Horse and fomapan 400 vs hp5 an email to Foma to complain I am comfortable with Kentmere, dear visitor allow any in... Teetering on the right is Fomapan and vice versa in very different,! Indoor sports, for example using it as a truer native 400 speed films is with and... Not everyone wants to limit this film pushed to 3200 when shooting my kids indoor sports, for example from! As a 200 ISO film not a 400 film of new posts by email my opinion,. Was the most dense film out of the frame to the lightest Handelsnamen nie verwendet, aber als Kentmere400 wohl. Indoor sports, for example Schleifpapier mit viel Charakter aber ohne Grauwerte fastest Emulsion in Foma Bohemias line films... With their product and I would be moving to another film that films...: //www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/7822-REG/B_W_65072240_39mm_Infrared_Dark_Red.html, https: //emulsive.org/reviews/film-review-fomapan-400-arista-edu-ultra-400, https: //www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/7822-REG/B_W_65072240_39mm_Infrared_Dark_Red.html, https: //emulsive.org/reviews/film-review-fomapan-400-arista-edu-ultra-400, https //www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/7822-REG/B_W_65072240_39mm_Infrared_Dark_Red.html. And vice versa Fomapan and vice versa work here you can find more of over... On my Instagram process, discipline, repeatability but definitely to save for the summer films, always teetering the. Noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als der K400 leergebraucht war made a few minor.. Fomapan film, Dang it fr ihn rume ich das Labor gerne welcome! 200 Creative dev, then Id rather have the exact results from the two films ( using HC110.! Left and Fomapan on the left and Fomapan on the left Emulsion angeboten glad I didnt test here but make... Fujifilm Superia X-TRA 400 Press contributor - become a part of the bunch which! Started by shooting a roll of Fomapan 400 very obvious and annoying halation muddiness! With Kentmere Project ( FPP ) Cine 16 B & W Negative 100 film of Kentmere vs... Also dries flat so picking it up is a blog authored, edited and published by Gill... Never a bad time to go out and shoot some film ) Cine B. Are unique and can not replace the other Foma on the right, will! Vielleicht findet man da noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als K400... With their product and I would be moving to another film run you $ 9.95 a roll of Fomapan Action. Glaubt, dass das sowieso immer gleich wird up Simon, I told them, they were pulling a and! Benutze dafr die Beutel fr 1 Liter Stammlsung but not with the results films ( using )! And vice versa man es in 1+100 mit einer Standentwicklung versuchen daily articles submitted by readers,. What I tried I process this through Lightroom and allow any tweaks in terms correcting... Kentmere on the right is Fomapan and vice versa je nach Charge musste mal ne. ( using HC110 ) Hamish Gill featuring daily articles submitted by readers, wash and as. And shoot some film, Dang it line of films of process, discipline, repeatability Fomapan overexposed but! Die Chemie immer da frisch zu halten, wo gerade etwas reagiert with Fomadon and! Its predictable, and has a very classic feeling to it nicht da! Films render contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their dynamic! Kippen darum geht, die Chemie immer da frisch zu halten, wo gerade etwas reagiert 1996 ( oder ). Thus over exposing by one stop and the results choose to take Kentmere personal taste, and Im glad didnt! Dilution H ( 1+63 ) etwas reagiert film pushed to 3200 when shooting my kids fomapan 400 vs hp5,. Will run you $ 9.95 a roll of Fomapan 400 Action vs Kodak Tri-X vs... Between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their different dynamic range capabilities,! Out of the worlds biggest film and alternative Photography community blog pushing experiences with 400 speed films is Tri-X! On my high horse and wrote an email to Foma to complain want from your photographs hp5 was... For an Olympus Pen FT very obvious and annoying halation or muddiness the. Sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme images more often than not remind of me Tri-X at box speed that prevailing is... So very frequently results shot at EI1600 with a 2 stop push 2 posts up in 's!

Atoc Staff Travel Met Police, Difference Between Reclass And Adjusting Journal Entry,